Comparison
Comparison of ResMed AirSense 10 and Philips DreamStation 2
Sep
Features, Specifications, and User Insights
The ResMed AirSense 10 and Philips DreamStation 2 are both popular CPAP devices, each offering unique features tailored for sleep apnea therapy. The AirSense 10 is known for its quiet operation, integrated humidifier, and advanced AutoSet algorithms that adjust pressure based on individual needs. It also has an easy-to-read display and user-friendly controls. The DreamStation 2, on the other hand, is compact, designed for easy travel, and features intuitive touchscreen controls. It provides advanced data tracking and can connect to the Philips DreamMapper app, enabling users to monitor their therapy progress. Both devices are reliable choices, with the AirSense 10 focusing on comfort and ease of use, while the DreamStation 2 emphasizes portability and modern tech integration.
Overview
The AirSense 10 by ResMed is renowned for its compact design, quiet operation, and advanced features like AutoRamp and Expiratory Pressure Relief (EPR). The built-in humidifier and cellular connectivity make it a popular choice for CPAP therapy.
The DreamStation 2 by Philips Respironics, a more recent model, offers a modern, compact design with features like an integrated humidifier, Bluetooth connectivity, and a color touchscreen interface. It’s designed for easy portability and patient comfort.
Specifications Comparison
| Feature | ResMed AirSense 10 AutoSet | Philips Respironics DreamStation 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions (L x W x H) | 25.4 x 15.0 x 11.6 cm | 19.3 x 15.7 x 8.4 cm |
| Weight | 1.24 kg | 1.33 kg |
| Pressure Range | 4-20 cm H2O | 4-20 cm H2O |
| Sound Level | 26.6 dBA | 27.9 dBA |
| Ramp Feature | AutoRamp with sleep onset detection | Adjustable ramp time |
| Humidification | Integrated HumidAir humidifier | Integrated with adjustable settings |
| Data Reporting | Wireless connectivity, SD card | Bluetooth, SD card, and cloud reporting |
| Mask Compatibility | Compatible with all ResMed masks | Compatible with all Philips Respironics masks |
| Power Supply | 90W power supply | 65W power supply (with integrated power brick) |
| Climate Control | Optional ClimateLineAir tubing | Optional heated tube |
| Altitude Adjustment | Automatic up to 2,591 meters | Automatic up to 2,286 meters |
| Display | LCD with light sensor | Color touchscreen |
| Water Chamber Capacity | 380 ml | 325 ml |
| Connectivity | Built-in cellular | Built-in Bluetooth |
| FAA Approved | Yes | Yes |
| Compliance Tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 2 years | 2 years |
Additional Considerations
- User Experience and Comfort:
- AirSense 10: Offers AutoRamp for gradual pressure increase and EPR for easier exhalation, enhancing overall comfort during use.
- DreamStation 2: Features a color touchscreen and Flex technology, providing a user-friendly interface and natural breathing experience.
- Maintenance and Cleaning:
- Both devices have easy-to-remove water chambers and accessible filters, ensuring simple cleaning and maintenance.
- Environmental and Altitude Adaptability:
- AirSense 10 adjusts automatically up to 2,591 meters, making it suitable for higher altitudes, whereas the DreamStation 2 adjusts up to 2,286 meters.
- Noise Levels:
- AirSense 10 is slightly quieter at 26.6 dBA compared to the DreamStation 2 at 27.9 dBA, making it a better option for light sleepers.
- Travel and Portability:
- DreamStation 2 is more compact and travel-friendly due to its smaller size and integrated power brick, while the AirSense 10 is slightly larger and uses a separate power supply.
- Data Tracking and Connectivity:
- The AirSense 10 offers built-in cellular connectivity for robust data tracking and remote monitoring via app (where is available).
- The DreamStation 2 focuses on Bluetooth and integrates with the DreamMapper app for real-time feedback(where is available).
- Accessories and Mask Compatibility:
- Both machines are compatible with a wide range of masks from their respective manufacturers, with optional heated tubing available for climate control.
- Cost Considerations:
- The AirSense 10 might be slightly less expensive while the DreamStation 2 is competitively priced.
- Warranty and Support:
- Both devices come with a 2-year warranty, with good customer support networks, though recent recalls of earlier DreamStation models might be a consideration.
- Current Market Trends:
- The AirSense 10 remains popular due to its reliability, while the DreamStation 2 is gaining traction for its advanced features and modern design.
Conclusion
Both the ResMed AirSense 10 and Philips DreamStation 2 are excellent choices for CPAP therapy, offering a range of features that enhance comfort and compliance. Your choice will largely depend on personal preferences related to design, interface, and specific feature needs. The DreamStation 2 may appeal to those seeking a more compact, modern device with a touchscreen interface, while the AirSense 10 is ideal for those who prioritize quiet operation, larger humidifier capacity and built quiality.